… ist eine groß­ar­ti­ge Geschi­che mei­ner LK-Schü­le­rin Eli­sa­beth Weber. Bis zum Schluss fragt man sich WER die Geschich­te eigent­lich erzählt. Die Geschich­te ist ein her­vor­ra­gen­des Bei­spiel für einen unre­lia­ble nar­ra­tor und für defa­mi­lia­riza­ti­on (vgl. Lodge Die Kunst des Erzäh­lens, Kap. 11).

Withered Hopes

Man­ny was trap­ped in pitch-black. She could­n’t even see her own shi­ny cove­ring. Alt­hough she did­n’t look it, she was smar­ter than most peo­p­le around her. She tried to con­cen­tra­te on her sur­roun­dings, but her thoughts were slow­ly drif­ting away under the sopo­ri­fic sounds from the underground.Simon had memo­ri­zed his litt­le speech a gazil­li­on times, it see­med to her. How he would ring her door­bell and her sur­pri­se about his appearance would melt into hap­pi­ness. Saman­tha, I’m so sor­ry. If I could go back in time, I would care more. I would be the­re for you when­ever you need me. Wit­hout you, my sun does­n’t shi­ne. Wit­hout you, I am not­hing. He had said tho­se five litt­le sen­ten­ces over and over again, so that Man­ny was­n’t sure, if asked, she’d say her name was Man­ny or Saman­tha. Not that she could say any­thing, but still. How ridi­cu­lous some peo­p­le beha­ved, living in their own world of illusions.And Man­ny was the­re to help Simon. After all, he was the only one to have ever tal­ked to her, not caring that she would­n’t ans­wer him.Absent-minded, she noti­ced that someone had sett­led right across from her.“Do you mind?“ It was an old man’s voice.

“Of cour­se not.“ That was Simon’s voice.

“Are you going to Beck­ton Park, too?“

“No. The one after that.“

“Visi­ting someone?“

“Yes.“

Man­ny could hear the irri­ta­ti­on about the nosy man in Simon’s voice. Alt­hough she could only guess, the man must have been smi­ling encou­ra­gin­gly, so Simon continued.

“My ex-girl­fri­end.“ And after a pau­se: “It’s all my fault. I for­got the flowers.”

Now it was the old man’s turn to be irri­ta­ted. “The flowers?”

“Yes, the flowers. They were her ever­y­thing. After work she would go out in the gar­den and nur­se them. And on Sun­days, we would sit among­st them and she’d look beau­tiful. She was so beau­tiful …” His voice trai­led off. It star­ted to rain. The­re was only the con­stant sound from the under­ground and the rain pat­te­ring against the window.

After a while, the old man cle­ared his throat. “So she had some some flowers.” Simon came to life again: “Some? The house and the gar­den were over­flowing! She was so beau­tiful with all the flowers …”

“Yes. Sure. But how come you and her … I mean, what hap­pen­ed?” Simon sig­hed. “She went to Dub­lin to visit a fri­end from Col­lege. Two weeks in the midst of sum­mer. I had to take care of her flowers. She had writ­ten two pages of ins­truc­tions. When I had to water which flowers. She even asked me to talk to her favou­ri­te one, the blue Lily of the Nile. But I lost the ins­truc­tions and I for­got about it. I had never work­ed in a gar­den befo­re.” Simon’s voice tur­ned guilty.

“When she came back, the lilies were withe­red in the heat and she found the wate­ring can bro­ken. I did­n’t know it was bro­ken, but she thought I had done it. It must have been the cat, but that does­n’t mat­ter any­mo­re. She said she could­n’t belie­ve that I had been too lazy to get a new one. She did­n’t shout at me. She just loo­ked at me sad­ly. I could­n’t look her in the eye. The next day I left.”

It was silent again. Then Simon deci­ded he wan­ted to have some reassu­rance. Man­ny felt his hand lif­ting her up and was dazz­led by the light. “I bought a new one.” Man­ny smi­led an invi­si­ble smi­le. Simon always had to say the obvious when he was ner­vous. He poin­ted at the wate­ring can. “I even pain­ted the blue lilies on it.” Though a litt­le hurt by the “it” Man­ny was still proud of her fan­cy looks. It was hard not to get cocky.

“Do you think she’ll like it?”

“She’ll love it!”

“Real­ly?”

“Of cour­se, it’s wonderful!”

“They always do that kind of “meaningful pre­sent” stuff in films. Like in the new one. With that French actress and what’s‑his-name?”

“I don’t know, but I’m sure she’ll like it very much.”

Man­ny was so used to humans always flat­te­ring each other, and yet she could­n’t help but roll her ima­gi­na­ry eyes.

In the mean­ti­me they had come to Beck­ton Park, and the old man said “good-bye” and “good luck” poli­te­ly. They were the only ones left in the com­part­ment. Simon star­ted tap­ping his fin­gers ner­vous­ly on Man­ny, who rever­be­ra­ted softly.

Final­ly they arri­ved at their sta­ti­on and Simon hesi­tant­ly got up. Sud­den­ly he stopped.

Man­ny saw her. The tall, slen­der woman not alo­ne. His arm around her neck and kis­sing her light­ly, a man came towards their com­part­ment. Man­ny felt a sharp air draft befo­re she hit the ground. Simon was shaking hea­vi­ly and got off the train very quick­ly. He was alre­a­dy gone when Man­ny had found her ori­en­ta­ti­on again.

She smells like a rose, she thought befo­re she slid under a seat as the train accelerated.

It did­n’t mat­ter anymore.